Frederick Douglass famously called the US Constitution a “glorious liberty document.” Historians have often dismissed the claim as mere political strategy or borrowed abolitionist rhetoric. In his groundbreaking new book, Until the Last Yoke Is Broken: The Constitutional Vision of Frederick Douglass (Harvard University Press), BYU Law Associate Professor Bradley N. Rebeiro argues otherwise, and he joined Stanford Law Professor Jud Campbell to discuss why. Rebeiro contends that the claim reflects Douglass’s own distinctive theory of constitutional law and interpretation. His book traces that theory from the late antebellum crisis over slavery through Reconstruction, when Douglass shifted his focus toward the right to vote. Campbell praised Rebeiro’s book as both a portrait of Douglass and a history of nineteenth-century American constitutionalism. He highlighted how it recovers an older view that the Constitution rests on natural rights, natural law, and the social contract rather than on text alone.
The conversation centered on what Rebeiro calls Douglass’s “natural rights originalism,” the belief that the Constitution’s meaning is fixed but must always be read through the lens of natural rights. Campbell noted that this way of thinking shaped both the nation’s founding and Reconstruction before giving way to the text-focused approach that dominates modern constitutional debate. Asked whether this theory can still inform constitutional interpretation, Rebeiro observed that natural law remains discoverable through reason and experience. “This is not something that is beholden only to the founders,” he said. “It’s just as accessible to us today as it was to them in the past.”
