Moot Court Finals

November 13, 2018

On Friday, February 10, 2017, BYU Law congratulated the winners of the annual Moot Court final competition. Brenden Stuart won best oralist and Karen Sullivan won runner-up.

The three distinguished members of the court were Justice Jeff Brown of the Texas Supreme Court, Chief Justice Lee Rosenthal of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Texas, and Judge Randolph Moss of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. Judge Moss complimented the finalists, “I would love to see any one of you in my courtroom. I hope I do someday.”

Stuart and Sullivan both prepared extensively for the final competition. “I was most nervous about trying to fill the shoes of the competitors that went last year,” Stuart said. “I remember watching last year’s 2Ls compete and thinking how impressive they were.”

Both finalists learned valuable lessons from their Moot Court experience. “I learned that I can trust myself on the spot,” Sullivan said. “I was worried that I wouldn’t be able to answer spontaneous questions well, but as I trusted the preparation I put in, everything worked out just fine.” Stuart learned the principle of being a “reasonable attorney.” “There really is no need to stand up and argue a point that is not critical to your case,” he said. “In line with that, taking a stand that goes farther than you need to win can be damaging. Concessions, when appropriate, actually help you focus your argument to the critical points that need to be discussed in the limited time period you have.”

Stuart and Sullivan found the “real-life experience” they gained in the competition to be the most rewarding. “Having the opportunity to argue a case in front of real judges was an incredible opportunity,” Stuart said. “I would say that opportunity alone was the most rewarding part of this competition.” Sullivan added, “Seeing the red time card and to still be standing on my feet was gratifying.”

Both Stuart and Sullivan are eager to implement the judges’ advice and improve their skills as future lawyers.